What If I’m Not Sure I Really Want to Stay in This Marriage?

It’s one of those thoughts that creeps in quietly but carries a ton of weight.

You’ve hurt your spouse. You’ve made promises to work on things. Maybe you’ve even started that process: therapy, honesty, full transparency. But somewhere deep inside, there’s still this unsettled question you haven’t said out loud:

What if I’m not sure I want to stay?

It can feel like a betrayal on top of the betrayal just to admit that. You may be asking yourself, Does that make me a terrible person? Am I wasting their time? Or maybe it’s more subtle, like a low-grade numbness, a disconnection that hasn’t fully gone away.

To be clear though, feeling uncertain does not make you a monster.

Affairs don’t just expose the cracks in a relationship. They expose the cracks in you. And often, when the adrenaline dies down and the truth is out, you’re left facing a question you never wanted to deal with: What do I really want?

When you're unsure if you want to stay in the marriage

People tend to think the affair happened because of the marriage. But in most cases, the deeper issue is disconnection: from your values, from your voice, from parts of yourself you shut down years ago.

So if you’re sitting in that place of uncertainty, here’s a hard but important truth. Until you get honest with yourself, you won’t have clarity about the marriage.

Right now, your energy might be going into image management. Trying to keep the peace. Hoping your spouse will calm down. Worrying about how you look. But none of that gets you closer to knowing what’s real for you.

Clarity doesn’t come from trying harder to fix the relationship. It comes from understanding who you’ve been, how you’ve been showing up (or not showing up), and whether you’re actually willing to become the kind of person a real partnership requires.

Because here’s the thing.

You can’t make a clear decision about the relationship while you’re still living in survival mode.

And neither can your spouse. 

What if you're afraid to say you're not sure?

That fear makes sense. You don’t want to hurt your spouse more. You’re afraid that if you speak your uncertainty out loud, it will shatter what’s left. Or maybe you think being honest will mean walking away, and that feels overwhelming or even selfish.

But the truth is, staying silent about your uncertainty is its own kind of harm. It keeps both of you stuck in a relationship that may not be grounded in reality, and it prevents healing no matter what path you eventually choose.

You don’t have to have all the answers right now. You just have to be willing to stop avoiding the question. 

What to do when you're unsure about staying

If this is where you are, here’s what I suggest.

Stop focusing on the marriage for a moment and start focusing on yourself.
Not in a self-centered way, but in a self-accountable way. Get honest about your patterns. What did the affair expose in you? What parts of you have been on autopilot? What are you afraid to face?

Let go of the fantasy that clarity comes through comfort.
It doesn’t. It comes through discomfort, through being honest about your own ambivalence, and then choosing whether or not you’re willing to become a safe, transparent, emotionally available partner.

Don’t make decisions while you’re still foggy.
You don’t have to make a permanent call today. But you do need to start working toward clarity, not just coasting in confusion. 

If you’re stuck in the in-between, we can help you get clear

This is exactly what Linda and I work on with people in our mentoring sessions.

We don’t pressure you to stay. We don’t push you to leave. We help you get honest, get grounded, and get clear so that whatever choice you make, it comes from strength and truth, not guilt or fear.

If you’re tired of pretending and ready to do something real with the questions you’ve been carrying, we’re here.

Explore mentoring with us here

For those ready to face the truth, not just escape the pain.

If you’ve had an affair and you’re still carrying guilt, confusion, or that quiet fear that you might mess it all up again — you’re not alone. But staying stuck doesn’t help anyone, least of all you.

This isn’t about punishment.
It’s about clarity. Ownership. And becoming someone you can actually respect.

With mentoring, we’ll work together to uncover the deeper patterns behind what happened — not to excuse it, but to transform it. You’ll get honest, compassionate guidance rooted in lived experience — not theory. No judgment. No performance.

Just a place to get real, do the work, and become the partner, parent, and person you know you’re capable of being.

If you’re ready to stop hiding from yourself and start rebuilding from the inside out — I’m here.

From the World of Self-Improvement

Relationships

Emotional/Mental Well-being

Personal Growth

Physical Well-being

Professional and Financial

Feeling Stuck? Here's How We Can Help You Move Forward

When you're ready for more than just reading… here are two powerful ways to get traction in your healing journey: 

1. Start with a Program That Fits Where You Are. Whether you're the betrayed partner trying to survive the chaos—or the unfaithful partner trying to stop making it worse—there's a resource here that speaks directly to you. 

→ Survive and Thrive after Infidelity - For betrayed spouses ready to steady themselves and start rebuilding. 

This full program walks you (or your spouse) through what to expect after D-day, how to calm the emotional rollercoaster, and how to reclaim your power. 

→ Get the clarity and support you need to not just survive—but thrive. 

→ The Unfaithful Person's Guide to Helping Your Spouse Heal From Your Affair: For unfaithful partners who don’t want to keep guessing what helps. 

This guide covers the 24 critical tasks that shift you from betrayer to healer. It's not fluff—it’s the real work your partner needs to see from you.

→ Stop spinning in shame and start showing up differently. 

2. Talk to Someone Who Gets It - Sometimes, you don’t need more information. You need a real conversation with someone who’s been where you are.  Book a Mentoring Session 

Whether you're the betrayed or the unfaithful partner, mentoring gives you space to be heard, get honest, and receive personalized guidance.

→ Not just sympathy—real empathy. From people who’ve lived it.

Take care!

Linda & Doug

Emotional Affair Journey

You are receiving this email because you signed up for the Mend newsletter.

Was this email forwarded to you? Get your own sub here.