Should You Apologize to Your Affair Partner's Spouse?

Before we get started…

I got a question during a mentoring call this week that I've probably been asked fifty different ways over the years, and it made me realize I've never really talked about it here. The question was simple: "Should I reach out to my affair partner's spouse and apologize?"

On the surface, it sounds like a yes-or-no question. In reality, it usually isn't.

Most of the time there are a couple of other questions hiding underneath it. Questions about guilt and/or shame. Wanting to make things right. Wanting to be the kind of person who owns what they've done.

So this week I want to slow down and look at what's really behind that question. Not because there's one answer that fits everyone, but because before you reach out to someone whose life has already been turned upside down, it's worth asking who that apology is really for.

Featured Article…

Should You Apologize to Your Affair Partner's Spouse?

At some point in recovery, a lot of unfaithful people start thinking about the other betrayed spouse. Maybe you've imagined what they went through. Maybe you know who they are. Maybe you've thought about writing them a letter, calling them, or apologizing if you ever crossed paths.

On the surface, it seems like the right thing to do. You played a role in hurting someone who never did anything to you. Doesn't common decency say you should apologize?

Maybe. But there are other things to think about besides common decency.

There's your spouse's healing. There's the other spouse's healing. And there's the possibility that an apology you hope will help could actually make things harder for someone who's already been through enough.

Before you do anything, it's worth asking yourself what's really driving the desire to reach out.

Who is the apology really for?

This is the part most people don’t consider.

When you picture apologizing, what are you hoping will happen?

If you're honest, part of the answer is often relief. You want to do something with the guilt. You want to know you've owned what you did. Maybe, somewhere deep down, you're hoping they'll see that you're not a terrible person.

That's understandable. Shame makes people want to fix something, anything.

The problem is that if the main purpose of the apology is to help you feel better, then it's probably serving your needs more than theirs.

A question I sometimes ask in mentoring is this: If they never replied...never acknowledged the letter...never forgave you...would you still feel it was the right thing to do?

Your answer to that question tells you a lot about what's really motivating you.

What they usually need isn't you

Try looking at it from their side for a minute.

They're dealing with the same kind of devastation your own spouse is trying to recover from. They're sorting through lies, wondering what was real, trying to decide whether their relationship can survive.

Now imagine getting a letter or phone call from the other person involved in the affair.

Even if it's sincere, it can reopen wounds they're just beginning to deal with. It can bring up questions they weren't asking. It can force them to revisit something they were trying to process on their own terms.

For some people, that contact might be helpful. For many others, it's just one more reminder of the worst period of their life.

The truth is, you don't know which category they fall into.

Your own spouse needs honesty, consistency, and accountability from you. That's where your energy belongs.

The other spouse's healing usually doesn't depend on hearing from you. It depends on their own process, their own relationship, and their own decisions.

One more thing to keep in mind. You have no way of knowing what that relationship looks like behind closed doors. You don't know how the other spouse will respond, whether your contact will bring clarity or simply create more chaos.

In some situations, it could even escalate conflict or put someone in an unsafe position. That's another reason to be very cautious about assuming an apology will automatically help.

When it can make sense

This isn't an absolute rule. But sometimes contact is appropriate.

If the other betrayed spouse reaches out to you and asks questions, answer them honestly. Don't dodge. Don't minimize. Don’t lie. Don't volunteer information they didn't ask for, but don't hide from the truth either.

Your own spouse should know it's happening, and there shouldn't be any surprises.

In some situations, it also helps to have a therapist involved so everyone understands the purpose of the conversation.

The difference is who started it.

Responding because someone asked you for the truth is very different from deciding on your own that they need to hear from you.

Talk to your own spouse first

If you're seriously thinking about contacting your affair partner's spouse, don't start with them. Start with your own spouse.

Tell them what you've been thinking about. Tell them why. Let them respond.

If they find out later that you contacted the other spouse without telling them, you've just created another secret. Another decision that affected your marriage without including them.

That's not going to help rebuild trust.

The guilt you feel about the other spouse is real. It should bother you. But most of the time, the way through that guilt isn't by writing a letter to a stranger.

It's by continuing to do the hard work of becoming a safer, more honest spouse to the person you actually married.

If you're struggling with guilt and you're not sure what to do with it, whether it's guilt over what you put your spouse through, the impact on your affair partner's spouse, or just the person you became during the affair, you don't have to figure it out by yourself.

These are the kinds of conversations I have all the time with unfaithful men and women. We take your specific situation, sort through what's really going on, and help you figure out what your next steps should be. If you'd like to learn more or schedule a private phone session, you can get started here: Individual Mentoring

What I’m Seeing This Week…

Renee had been thinking about writing the same letter for weeks. She wanted to apologize to Paul, the husband of the man she'd had the affair with. She hadn't sent anything, but she couldn't stop thinking about it.

She felt like he deserved to hear that she was sorry.

I asked her what she hoped would happen if she sent the letter.

She responded with something like, "Honestly...I think I'd finally feel like I'd done everything I could."

That answer told us where we needed to start.

So, we talked about what receiving that letter might actually be like for Paul. Imagine opening an envelope from someone who played a part in blowing up your marriage. Even if every word is sincere, it still brings all of that pain right back into your living room.

I also asked Renee whether her husband knew she'd been thinking about writing it. He didn't. I suggested that she should.

She talked with him later that week. He understood why she felt guilty, but the thought of her reaching back into that family's life, even with good intentions, felt like reopening a chapter they were both trying to leave behind.

In the end, she never sent the letter.

Instead, she worked on how to stop looking for a way to ease her guilt somewhere else and started working through it honestly with her husband.

Two Small Steps for the Week…

For yourself:

Before you contact your affair partner's spouse, be brutally honest with yourself about what you're hoping will happen. Write it down if it helps.

Are you trying to help them, or are you hoping to ease your own guilt or finally feel forgiven? If your answer leans more toward your own relief, don't rush into it.

Spend some time understanding what's driving that urge before you decide whether acting on it is really the right thing to do.

For the relationship:

If you've been thinking about contacting the other spouse, talk to your own spouse before you do anything. Don't let them find out afterward.

Tell them why you've been considering it, listen to their concerns without becoming defensive, and let them be part of the decision.

Even if you ultimately decide not to reach out, having that conversation openly is another opportunity to practice the honesty and transparency you're trying to rebuild.

Why the “Why” Really Matters

A lot of people who’ve had an affair spend months, even years, trying to figure out why it happened. They circle around guilt, shame, and confusion but never quite get to real answers. 

That’s where the Root Cause Analysis Mentoring Program comes in. It’s a simple, focused way to dig deeper and understand what really went wrong beneath the surface. You know…the stuff that keeps you stuck if you don’t face it. 

If you’ve been saying things like, “I don’t even know why I did it,” or if your spouse keeps asking that same question and you can’t give a clear answer, this program is for you. 

It’s not about blame or excuses. It’s about clarity, honesty, and learning how to make sure it never happens again. 

If that sounds like something you need, take a look.

Deeper Dive

If today’s insight hit home and you want support applying it, here’s how we can help

That’s a Wrap!

Here’s what to do if you want real progress:

1. Get clear on your “why.”

The Root Cause Analysis Intensive help you understand the deeper patterns behind the affair so you can finally change them.

2. Learn exactly how to support your spouse.

The Unfaithful Person's Guide shows you what actually helps them feel safer (not what you assume helps).

3. Learn exactly how to support your spouse.

If you’re stuck in guilt, shame, fear, or confusion, individual mentoring gives you steady support and real direction.

Take one step at a time and take care!

Linda & Doug

Emotional Affair Journey

You are receiving this email because you signed up for the Mend newsletter.

Was this email forwarded to you? Get your own sub here.